Recruitment FAQs: Answers to Common Recruitment and Talent Questions

Hiring the right person is one of the most important decisions a business makes. It’s also one of the areas where employers have the most questions.

What can you ask in an interview? Are unpaid trials allowed? How do you know if someone will actually fit in?

Here are the recruitment questions we hear most often from business owners and hiring managers, along with our answers.

How long should recruitment take?

It depends on the role, the market and how organised the process is. A straightforward role might be filled in a few weeks. Senior, specialist or hard-to-fill roles can take considerably longer.

What we’d caution against is letting the process drag. Strong candidates often have more than one option, and a slow process is one of the most common reasons good people drop out or accept another offer. Agree on your timeline, interview panel and decision points before you advertise.

Should I include the salary in the job ad?

We’d recommend it in most cases. It isn’t a legal requirement, but candidates increasingly expect it, and ads with a salary range tend to attract more relevant applications.

Including the range also saves time for everyone. There’s nothing more frustrating than reaching the final stage only to discover your expectations and the candidate’s are miles apart. Our guide to writing effective job advertisements has more tips on writing ads that work.

What questions can’t I ask in an interview?

Avoid any question that relates to a protected attribute and isn’t genuinely relevant to the role. Under federal and Victorian anti-discrimination laws, this includes questions about:

  • Age
  • Pregnancy or plans to have children
  • Marital status or family responsibilities
  • Religion
  • Race, nationality or ethnic background
  • Disability or health, unless it relates directly to the inherent requirements of the role
  • Sexual orientation or gender identity

The simplest test is to ask yourself whether the question helps you assess the person’s ability to do the job. If it doesn’t, leave it out. For example, instead of asking “Do you have young kids?”, ask “This role involves some early starts. Is that something you can manage?” Our article on interview questions offers questions that actually help you make better decisions.

Are unpaid work trials allowed?

Only in very limited circumstances, and this is where many employers get caught out.

An unpaid trial is generally only acceptable if it’s purely to demonstrate skills relevant to the role, lasts no longer than needed to do that, and the candidate is directly supervised throughout. Depending on the role, that might be an hour or, at most, a single shift.

If the person is doing productive work for the business, such as serving customers or completing real tasks, they should be paid. When in doubt, pay them. It’s a small cost compared with the risk.

How do I assess cultural fit without being biased?

This is a great question, because “cultural fit” can easily become a polite way of saying “people like us”.

A better approach is to think about values alignment and culture add. Be clear about the values and behaviours that genuinely matter in your workplace, such as reliability, teamwork or customer focus, and assess candidates against those consistently. At the same time, look for what the person might bring that your team doesn’t already have.

Using the same questions and scoring criteria for every candidate helps reduce bias. Our guide to candidate assessment goes into this in more detail.

Do I need permission to contact referees?

Yes. You should always get the candidate’s consent before contacting referees and only contact the referees they’ve nominated.

When you do speak to referees, ask about specific examples of the candidate’s work and behaviour rather than general questions like “Were they good?”. Questions like “Can you tell me about a time they handled a difficult customer?” tend to give far more useful answers.

Can I run a police check?

You can, with the candidate’s written consent, but it should be relevant to the role. For example, a police check makes sense for roles involving vulnerable people, money or security.

Keep in mind that a criminal record doesn’t automatically disqualify someone. Consider whether the record is genuinely relevant to the inherent requirements of the job, and be aware that spent convictions laws may limit what you can take into account. Some roles also require separate checks, such as a Working with Children Check.

How do I check someone has the right to work in Australia?

If the candidate isn’t an Australian citizen, you should check their visa status and any work conditions before they start. The Department of Home Affairs’ VEVO system allows employers to do this online with the candidate’s consent.

Make it a standard part of your process for every relevant candidate, keep a record of the check and diarise visa expiry dates. Employers can face significant penalties for allowing someone to work in breach of their visa conditions.

What do I need to give a new employee when they start?

All new employees must receive the Fair Work Information Statement. Casual employees must also receive the Casual Employment Information Statement, and fixed-term employees must receive the Fixed Term Contract Information Statement.

Beyond the legal requirements, a clear written contract, a position description and a structured induction help set expectations from day one. Our article on onboarding success explains why the first few weeks matter so much.

Why are candidates turning down our offers?

This is one of the most common frustrations we hear. The usual reasons include a slow process, salary that doesn’t match expectations, a poor interview experience or a counteroffer from their current employer.

Sometimes the issue is how the business comes across during recruitment. Candidates are assessing you just as closely as you’re assessing them. We explore this further in why candidates are declining offers.

What are the most common hiring mistakes?

The ones we see most often are:

  • Hiring in a rush to fill a gap
  • An unclear brief about what the role actually needs
  • Relying too heavily on gut feel
  • Inconsistent interviews between candidates
  • Skipping reference checks
  • Overselling the role or the business
  • Neglecting onboarding once the person accepts

Our article on common hiring mistakes explains how to avoid each one.

When should I use a recruitment partner?

A recruitment partner can be particularly valuable when:

  • The role is senior, specialist or hard to fill
  • You don’t have the time or internal resources to run a thorough process
  • You’ve had trouble attracting the right candidates
  • The role is confidential
  • A poor hire would be especially costly

A good recruitment partner does more than send resumes. They help shape the brief, reach candidates who aren’t actively looking and bring an objective eye to the assessment. Learn more about our talent acquisition and recruitment services.

Final Word

Most recruitment problems can be avoided with a clear brief, a consistent process and an honest picture of what the role and the business offer.

Get those right, and you’ll attract better candidates, make more confident decisions and set new employees up to succeed from the start.

Have a recruitment question we haven’t covered?

Whether you’re hiring for a critical role, reviewing your recruitment process or struggling to find the right people, our team can help with practical advice and recruitment support built on years of real experience.

Speak with our HR Consultants

Share
[Sassy_Social_Share]